Menu
English

'Order of the Phoenix’s' Hidden Tragedy: A Deleted Scene Too Intense for the Film

Still from the movie 'Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix' (2007)

Now one of the main villains of the entire franchise will be hated even more.

The Harry Potter film franchise, while following the main events of the book series it is based on, does not always leave minor details as they are — and perhaps this was a good decision. For example, watching Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is already a struggle for fans due to the presence of the authoritarian Hogwarts headmistress Dolores Umbridge, but in reality, the scene with Harry's punishment could have had a much more tragic subtext.

In the book, Harry did not tell anyone about Umbridge's bullying — not even Ron and Hermione.

Still from the movie 'Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix' (2007)

In the film version of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry's secret about having to go to Umbridge's office for 'detention' after regular classes stops being a secret almost immediately — Hermione notices the cuts on Harry's hands and forces him to tell her the whole truth. In the book, however, the situation is a bit different — Harry never confesses to his friends that the detentions cause him physical pain, and when Ron and Hermione ask what Harry has to do as punishment, he replies that he simply writes the same phrase over and over again. Notably, in this case, Ron and Hermione see nothing wrong with it and even acknowledge that Harry has gotten off relatively easy.

The change in this detail in the film led to the creation of a very accurate storyline that demonstrates violence. In the book, Harry himself did not understand why he ultimately did not tell Ron and Hermione about what was happening — it's quite clear that it was fear and his own shock at what was happening to him that kept him from exposing Umbridge even to his close friends. The cruel headmistress knew very well that everything that happened in her office would stay there, and Harry preferred to try to forget everything and distance himself from the situation — this made Ron and Hermione's comments about the punishment not being that severe even more cruel.

Spells, Names, and Hidden Meanings — The Etymology of the 'Harry Potters' Wizarding World Spells, Names, and Hidden Meanings — The Etymology of the 'Harry Potters' Wizarding World Read more 27 April 2025
How a Five-Year-Old Boy Became Part of Two Oscar-Winning Masterpieces: The Story of Giorgio Cantarini How a Five-Year-Old Boy Became Part of Two Oscar-Winning Masterpieces: The Story of Giorgio Cantarini Read more 29 April 2025
There Are Special Deleted Scenes in 'Deathly Hallows': Viewers Cry, Even Though They Feature the Dreaded Dursleys There Are Special Deleted Scenes in 'Deathly Hallows': Viewers Cry, Even Though They Feature the Dreaded Dursleys Read more 29 April 2025
'The Legend of Ochi' – A Creature Tale Cloaked in Mystery: Should You Follow the Call Into the Wild? 'The Legend of Ochi' – A Creature Tale Cloaked in Mystery: Should You Follow the Call Into the Wild? Read more 29 April 2025
'Naruto' could be Completely Different: A Ramen Shop Version Likely Wouldn’t be a Hit 'Naruto' could be Completely Different: A Ramen Shop Version Likely Wouldn’t be a Hit Read more 29 April 2025
Behind the Vatican Walls: How Movies Twist the Truth of the Papal Election Behind the Vatican Walls: How Movies Twist the Truth of the Papal Election Read more 29 April 2025
They Cut 30 Minutes and Renamed It: Miyazaki’s Film Misrepresented in the U.S. for Years They Cut 30 Minutes and Renamed It: Miyazaki’s Film Misrepresented in the U.S. for Years Read more 28 April 2025
'Thunderbolts*': Why the New Marvel Movie Has an Asterisk at the End of its Title 'Thunderbolts*': Why the New Marvel Movie Has an Asterisk at the End of its Title Read more 28 April 2025
Lynch's Film Earned $7M on $15M Budget: Now a 21st Century Classic Lynch's Film Earned $7M on $15M Budget: Now a 21st Century Classic Read more 28 April 2025
Frodo Baggins Is 50 Years Old? Turns Out the Hobbit Heroes in 'The Lord of the Rings' Aren’t Youngsters At All: Pippin Is the Greenest Of Them All Frodo Baggins Is 50 Years Old? Turns Out the Hobbit Heroes in 'The Lord of the Rings' Aren’t Youngsters At All: Pippin Is the Greenest Of Them All Read more 28 April 2025
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Read more