Menu
English Русский
favorites

In This Harry Potter Film, There Is a Significant Difference from the Book: and It Is Truly Strange

In This Harry Potter Film, There Is a Significant Difference from the Book: and It Is Truly Strange

The discrepancy significantly affects the plot.

In the film Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1, there is one strange detail that significantly differs from the book. Imagine this: Voldemort and his Death Eaters are spreading terror across the country, the Order of the Phoenix is hiding Harry Potter, who is the Dark Lord's most desired target. And suddenly... a wedding. Amidst the grim events, the Weasleys decide to throw a lavish celebration with many guests. But the most astonishing part is that Harry, whose appearance is known throughout magical Britain, walks among the guests without any disguise. This seems like a blatant disregard for safety!

In the film, Harry's protection truly appears minimal—no one is concerned that there might be Voldemort's spies or people under the Imperius Curse among the guests. What about Moody's command to "stay vigilant"? In the book, the situation unfolds quite differently: the members of the Order take security very seriously. The location of Harry's refuge is kept in the strictest secrecy, and on the day of the wedding, he disguises himself as 'cousin Barny Weasley' using Polyjuice Potion to avoid being recognized.

'Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows'

Such a level of secrecy fooled all the guests except Luna Lovegood, who recognized Harry simply 'by the expression on his face.' Seeing how thoroughly the Order of the Phoenix protects Harry in the book, the carelessness in the film seems at least strange. Of course, one can understand the screenwriters, as fitting all the details of the book into a two-hour film is not easy, but this moment leaves the impression that Harry's protection was not well thought out.

Yes, cinema is an art of compromises, but sometimes simplifications contradict the logic of the plot and characters.

The Actress Who Played Ginny Named the Key Problem with All the Harry Potter Films The Actress Who Played Ginny Named the Key Problem with All the Harry Potter Films Read more 26 December 2024
Magical Millions and Logical Problems: How the Economy Works in the Wizarding World of Harry Potter Magical Millions and Logical Problems: How the Economy Works in the Wizarding World of Harry Potter Read more 26 December 2024
The Legendary Movie Nearly Banned, and Hermione Is to Blame: How and Why 'Harry Potter' Almost Became a Film 'for Adults' The Legendary Movie Nearly Banned, and Hermione Is to Blame: How and Why 'Harry Potter' Almost Became a Film 'for Adults' Read more 25 December 2024
Following in the Footsteps of 'Game of Thrones': 5 Details that were Changed in the Harry Potter Films — and they Stopped Making Sense Following in the Footsteps of 'Game of Thrones': 5 Details that were Changed in the Harry Potter Films — and they Stopped Making Sense Read more 29 December 2024
J.K. Rowling Wrote About Scotland, But What's Shown In The Films? We Found Out Where Hogwarts From 'Harry Potter' is located J.K. Rowling Wrote About Scotland, But What's Shown In The Films? We Found Out Where Hogwarts From 'Harry Potter' is located Read more 28 December 2024
Only Muggles Could Have Missed Them: Embarrassing Mistakes from 'Harry Potter' That You Might Not Have Noticed Only Muggles Could Have Missed Them: Embarrassing Mistakes from 'Harry Potter' That You Might Not Have Noticed Read more 27 December 2024
Voldemort’s Greenish Skin Tone Isn’t Random: J.K. Rowling Thought It Through Voldemort’s Greenish Skin Tone Isn’t Random: J.K. Rowling Thought It Through Read more 27 December 2024
Was He Even Worse? 10 Important Details about Lucius Malfoy that Didn't Make It into the Harry Potter Films Was He Even Worse? 10 Important Details about Lucius Malfoy that Didn't Make It into the Harry Potter Films Read more 25 December 2024
Same Scars, Signs From the Future, Hermione's Death: Ron and Dumbledore are the Same Person, and This Theory Explains it All Same Scars, Signs From the Future, Hermione's Death: Ron and Dumbledore are the Same Person, and This Theory Explains it All Read more 24 December 2024
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Read more